Whether you want to reheat your leftover pizza or you want to bake up a frozen one, you need the right toaster oven.
There are many sizes of pizza ranging from mini all the way to humongous ones. The size that sits in between the range is the 12 inch pizzas. These are generally considered medium sized pizzas and are sufficient for most individuals – albeit I am not judging your appetite for pizzas.
Toaster ovens are generally considered the best way to cook or to reheat pizzas. Stoves are just not practical and microwaves oven do not retain the same taste and texture that you’d expect.
In this article, we will review the best toaster ovens for 12 inch pizza. Fortunately, there are plenty of choices out. We have picked up only those that stand out from the rest.
Also Read
Top 3 Toaster Ovens for 12 Inch Pizza
4.9/5
[Best Overall]
Cuisinart brand has a reputation for offering some of the best reliable and high-quality products in the market.
The brand doesn't disappoint with the Cuisinart DFP-14BCNY 14-cup Food Processor.
4.8/5
[Best for the Money]
Besides pizzas, the interior space on this oven can even allow you to cook an entire chicken in it. Speaking of which, this oven also offers a Rotisserie functions.
Therefore, if you love roasting meat along with your pizzas then this oven can come in quite handy.
4.7/5
[Best Wide Body Digital Option]
This wide toaster oven can fit 8 slices of bread or a 9”x13” pan. Furthermore, it has fully digital controls accessible via simple touch of buttons.
You can also use this oven to place wider trays for roasting veggies or for baking cake.
List of Best Toaster Ovens for 12 Inch Pizza in 2023
The following are the most ideal toaster oven for pizzas with a 12 inch diameter:
- Hamilton Beach 31123D – Manual Affordable Option
- Hamilton Beach 31103DA – Double Rack Manual Toaster Oven
- Black+Decker TO3290XSD – Wide Body Digital Option
- Breville BOV650XL – Compact Smart Oven
- COSORI CO130-AO – Multi-function High End Option
1. Hamilton Beach 31123D – Manual Affordable Option
This is a very small and compact regular toaster oven with a roll top door. It is excellent for those with a small counter space. Perfect of individual meal portions.
Hamilton Beach 31123D toaster oven is as simple as it gets when it comes to an option that supports as medium size 12 inch pizza.
It offers simple manual knob controls for setting temperature, timer as well as cooking mode. There a total of four modes here, bake, broil, toast ans convection.
It is worth noting that despite being a highly affordable toaster oven, this features a convection fan. This, for many, is essential for reheating or baking pizza since convection fan promotes even heating from all corners.
Furthermore, the oven is quite compact and also features a roll top door so that it does not occupy much space and is easy to access.
All in all, if you want the most economical model and if you do not care much for bells and whistles then we recommend this as the best toaster oven for 12 inch pizza.
This oven isn’t built for cooking meals as indicated by the mere 30 minutes timer. Instead, it is just built for simple reheating and toasting jobs
2. Hamilton Beach 31103DA – Double Rack Manual Toaster Oven
While this does not have digital controls, this affordable rotisserie convection toaster oven Wis excellent for those on a tight budget.
Like the previous oven, this is also a fairly simple oven with manual controls. However, what sets this apart are the obvious dual racks.
Both racks can be occupied with 12 inch pizzas. Therefore, if a single medium pizza just isn’t enough for you or if you wan to prepare multiple pizzas for your family quickly, then this can be the right choice.
Besides pizzas, the interior space on this oven can even allow you to cook an entire chicken in it. Speaking of which, this oven also offers a Rotisserie functions.
Therefore, if you love roasting meat along with your pizzas then this oven can come in quite handy.
Of course, with dual racks comes a larger footprint. As such, such you will require a larger counterspace to accommodate this model.
Again, this oven is more than just suitable for mere reheating pizzas. You can literally cook up meals in this as it has a timer of 120 minutes.
If you like more space and the ability to cook a higher number of pizzas, then this is certainly the best toaster oven for 12 inch pizzas for its price category.
3. Black+Decker TO3290XSD – Wide Body Digital Option
This wide toaster oven can fit 8 slices of bread or a 9”x13” pan. Furthermore, it has fully digital controls accessible via simple touch of buttons.
If you came here looking for an affordable DIGITAL toaster oven for your pizza needs, then you may find this an interesting choice.
For starters, being a digital oven, this takes away the trial and error testing from you. Instead, along with several other buttons, it offers a dedicated button for pizza. Pressing that will automatically select the right settings for preparing your pizza.
The oven can accommodate a single 12 inch pizza. However, note that the chamber on this oven is wider than normal. While others can fit 6 slices of toast, this can fit 8 slices of toast.
What this basically means is that you can also use this oven to place wider trays for roasting veggies or for baking cake.
Other than pizza, the toaster oven also has digital buttons for turning the convection on and off; for broil, bake and toast function; for common food items such as bagel and frozen foods; also a dedicated button for reheating.
Therefore, if you want an economical digital option with a compact form factor, then this is the best toaster oven for 12 inch pizza.
4. Breville BOV650XL – Compact Smart Oven
This toaster oven, albeit expensive, uses its proprietary Smart Element IQ technology for unprecedented control on heat. It can cook, toast and defrost evenly even without the convection feature for a regular sized family.
Next up we have one of the most advanced toaster oven for 12 inch pizza. Breville toaster ovens need no introduction. They have some of the most sought after models in the industry.
Breville BOV650XL follows in suit with the rest of the Smart Ovens line that feature the proprietary Element IQ technology.
With this, the oven uses PID heat sensors to control the 4 quartz heating elements independently and ensures that precise heat is provided to every corner.
Besides that, this oven comes with some of the most comprehensive setting for its presets. Not only can you select the right shade for your toast, you can choose from among 8 cooking functions.
The cooking functions on this include toast, bake, broil, and roast mode as well as presets for pizza, bagel, cookies and reheat.
Upon selecting the preset, the oven automatically calculates the right time and the temperature for you. The oven indicates both the time to preheat and when it cook on its large LCD.
All in all, if you want to stay on top of the curve with the most advanced option, then this is the best toaster oven for 12 inch pizza. Unfortunately, with all bells and whistles comes a greater price too.
5. COSORI CO130-AO – Multi-function High End Option
A highly versatile toaster oven with rotisserie that offers so much more including the Air Fryer and Dehydrator features.
This is the most expensive toaster oven in this list and if you came here looking for an option ONLY for pizza and nothing else, then previous ovens would do just fine for you.
However, if you want to bake 12 inch pizzas as well as explore your culinary horizons, then there is nothing better than this in our opinion.
This is more than just a toaster oven. Instead, this is a multi-cooker. Other than all the toaster oven functions such as bake, broil, roast and toast, this offers additional functions of an Air Fryer, Dehydrator, Fermenter and Rotisserie.
Due to its powerful convection fan, the toaster oven can literally double as an Air Fryer allowing you to cook without needing a deep fryer or loads of oil.
The Dehydrator can be used to create long lasting snacks and ingredients out of common foods. Furthermore, if you love to roast, then the dedicated rotisserie function on this can handle a whole 5 pound chicken.
All in all, this is a 12-in-1 toaster oven with a huger selection of functions. The large LCD screen on this not only displays all the cooking information, but is also used for navigation using the digital knob controllers below.
As such, you can literally automate all of your cooking needs with this. Of course, there are few issues with this. Firstly, it is expensive and therefore not suitable for everyone. Secondly, it has a large profile which can be hassle to accommodate if you have a limited kitchen space.
What Options Do You Have
When it comes to toaster ovens with a 12″ pizza capacity, there are plenty of choices out there.
Compact and Tall
You can find toaster ovens with both compact as well as a tall profile. The compact profile can help you if you have a limited counterspace.
On the other hand, a tall profile is great if you want to roast large sized meat like a whole chicken.
Digital and Manual
Digital toaster ovens provide comprehensive easy to use control and presets
You can find both manual toaster ovens as well as digital options.
The manual models follow the old school trend. You have to set the temperature and the timer manually and cooking or reheating in these takes a bit more care and monitoring.
Digital ovens, on the other hand, can give you a lot of easy to use functionality as well as control. Digital ovens come with cooking presets for common food especially pizza. Some also come with multiple cooking functions like dehydrator or an Air Fyer.
Price wise, manual toaster ovens are far cheaper than their digital counterparts.
Also Read: Best Digital Toaster Ovens
Double and Single Rack
You can find single and dual rack toaster ovens for 12 inch pizzas. Of course, a dual rack option is more expensive as it offers larger interior capacity.
The benefit of a dual rack toaster oven is that it can not only fit 2 x 12″ inch pizzas, it is also excellent for cooking large meals.
Final Words
The best toaster ovens for 12 inch pizzas listed above are great in one way or another. While some are budget friendly, others offer extensive features for cooking in general.
The one thing that we want you take away from this article is that there are plenty of great options for 12 inch pizzas out there and you can find them with myriad of feature combinations.
FAQs:
1. What are the best toaster ovens for 12 inch pizza?
List of Best Toaster Ovens for 12 Inch Pizza that we tested.
The following are the most ideal toaster oven for pizzas with a 12 inch diameter:
1. Hamilton Beach 31123D – Manual Affordable Option
2.
Hamilton Beach 31103DA – Double Rack Manual Toaster Oven
3.
Black+Decker TO3290XSD – Wide Body Digital Option
4.
Breville BOV650XL – Compact Smart Oven
5. COSORI CO130-AO – Multi-function High End Option
2. How long do you cook a pizza in a toaster oven?
It should take between 5 and 10 minutes to cook. The following are the steps.
Step1. Pre-heat the toaster oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, either on the bake or convection bake setting.
Step 2. Arrange the pizza or pizza slices on the toaster oven's rack and close the door.
Step 3. Bake for 5–10 minutes, depending on the size of the pizza.
On the convection setting, it may take less time.
3. Can you heat up pizza in a toaster oven?
Yes, a toaster oven can be used to reheat pizza. If you're only warming up one slice of pizza, reheating it in a toaster oven is the best option. Preheat your toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Bake your slice for three to four minutes on a medium heat, depending on its thickness.
4. What temperature can a pizza stone withstand?
Preheat the stone to 550° F (Pizzacraft stones can withstand temperatures of up to 900° F). If possible, the correct oven temperature for a pizza stone should be greater than 500° F. Arrange the pizza in the center of the stone at room temperature (do not season stone). Cook 5 minutes with the grill lid/oven door closed.
5. Can you make pizza in a normal oven?
Definitely, yes, the cooking process will be slightly different at these lower temperatures, but if you want to get as close to the real thing as possible, you'll need to crank up the oven! Thus, the optimal temperature for cooking homemade pizza in a domestic oven is approximately 250 degrees Celcius (about 500 degrees Fahrenheit).