5 Best Toaster Ovens for Frozen Pizza in 2023 Reviews | Including Must-Have Features

Who doesn’t love pizza. It is one of the few comfort foods that tastes awesome both fresh out of the oven as well as after being reheated.

If you have leftover or store bought frozen pizza, then you need a heating appliance that can do justice to its taste.

There are many cooking and reheating appliances like a microwave oven or even an air fryer, but none are more convenient than a toaster oven.

Toaster ovens retain the fresh taste and promote a crisp and brown texture for reheated frozen pizza. This is something that a microwave oven or a stove can never accomplish.

As such, if you are a pizza enthusiasts, here we will reviews some of the best toaster ovens for frozen pizza in 2023.

Also Read: Best Toaster Ovens with Rotisserie

List of Best Toaster Ovens for Frozen Pizza in 2023

1. Hamilton Beach 31123D – Convection – Single 12″ Pizza
2. Hamilton Beach 31401 – Budget Option – Single 9″ Pizza
3. Oster Extra Large Toaster Oven – Convection – Double 16″ Pizza
4. Breville BOV650XL Smart Toaster Oven – Single 12″ Pizza
5. Hamilton Beach 31156 – With Slot Toaster – Single 9″ Pizza

1. Hamilton Beach 31123D – Convection – Singe 12″ Pizza

If you want to make a beeline for one the most recommended toaster ovens for an average person, then we highly recommend this option.

It features a single rack with two rack positions and can fit a single 12″ Pizza or 6 slices of bread at a time. As such, whether it is a small pizza that you want to defrost or if it is just a couple of slices, this toaster oven should come in handy.

One of the greatest plus points about this oven is that it is a convection oven and therefore has a built in fan that circulates the hot air inside. This results in even heating on all corners of the pizza.

The convection feature can be turned on or off depending upon the food that you cook. For example, if you are baking, then you can keep the convection feature off.

Moreover, besides being a convection oven , it is quite affordable and within most people’s reach.

The maximum temperature this toaster oven can reach is 450° Fahrenheit with a maximum cook cycle of 30 minutes. However, when baking at high temperatures for prolonged time, caution should be taken.

Other features include easy access roll top door as well as a removable crumb tray.

The Hamilton Beach toaster oven is a great choice for those who have limited counter space and basic toaster oven needs. It is slightly larger than their previous toaster oven, but it comes with fantastic improvements. 

The easy open door is a standout feature, and the height is just right for under-counter clearance. The oven also cooks to accurate temperatures. 

For a first-time toaster oven user, this product is highly recommended as it is easy to use and understand.

It looks good, feels good, and is packed extremely well. Overall, it's an excellent purchase that seniors and everyone else will love.

In short, if you came here looking for a typical option, then this is the best toaster oven for frozen pizza.

2. Hamilton Beach 31401 – Budget Option – Single 9″ Pizza

Next up we have the cheapest option in this list.

This is a simple regular oven without the convection feature. It fits a single 9″ pizza or 4 slices of bread.

The benefit here is that it is not only cheap to procure, but is also cheap to operate thanks to its low 1100 watts power rating. Plus with a small chamber, it should do quick work of reheating any frozen pizza so you don’t have to keep the device turned on for long.

If you're looking for a compact yet functional toaster oven, the Hamilton Beach 31401 might just be what you need. It operates at a maximum temperature of 450° Fahrenheit and has a 30-minute timer with an auto shut-off feature.

Although it may not be the largest toaster oven out there, it offers convenience and saves counter space. The toasting setting can be a bit confusing, but it does work well.

Additionally, it comes with a removable crumb tray, making it easy to keep clean.

The oven has proven to be reliable, with no issues reported after a year of daily use. It's also great value for money, easy to use, and easy to clean. 

All in all, if you are looking for the cheapest option to toast a small pizza or individual slices, then this is the best toaster oven for frozen pizza in our opinion. It is very affordable and has also won favorable reviews.

3. Oster Extra Large Toaster Oven – Convection – Double 16″ Pizza

This is a large toaster oven capable of fitting not just one, but two 16″ sized pizzas.

This toaster oven is one of the most affordable dual rack extra large option in the market. For this reason, it has won a vast number of favorable reviews from its customers.

While it does not have a dedicated reheat option, it is particularly designed for baking, broiling, defrosting as well as toasting.

Unlike the previous options, it has a timer that can run for 90 minutes. As such, you can literally cook meals and in multiple batches if you have to.

If you have a crowd to feed, or if you regularly cook pizzas in an oven, then we highly recommend this option.

However, you must note that this toaster oven is designed for far more than just reheating a frozen pizza. You can literally cook oven recipes in this appliance including roasts, lasagna etc. Therefore, for mere reheating, this can be an overkill.

The Oster oven is a versatile and reliable kitchen appliance that can handle a range of cooking tasks with ease. Whether you're baking a cake or whipping up some mac and cheese, this oven can do it all.

With a variety of functions to choose from, it offers plenty of flexibility for different cooking needs. 

Iso much love the Oster oven's durability, as I've owned multiple models over the years. The newest one, with added Air Fry, has been a great addition to my kitchen.

While the air fryer rack isn't ideal for pizza, the oven cooks everything perfectly as long as you follow the recommended settings. Overall, it's a reliable and versatile appliance that I would highly recommend.

In short, if you want to reheat pizza and at the same time explore your culinary horizons, then this is the best toaster oven for frozen pizza.

4. Breville BOV650XL Smart Toaster Oven – Single 12″ Pizza

If you want to stay on top of the technological curve, then a smart toaster oven may appeal to you.

However, you must be warned here that Breville BOV650XL is a fairly expensive device. As such, you must really gauge whether the features here are truly needed.

For starters, this devices supports a single 12″ pizza or 4 slices of bread.

The real beauty of this devices lies in its Smart Element IQ technology. Instead of just dumbly heating all over the place, this oven has sensors that transfer accurate heat into the chamber.

The toaster oven has eight dedicated functions for cooking and heating up different foods including pizza. You just have to select the appropriate item using the knob.

You must note, however, that despite its small size, this oven can get super hot due to its 1800 wattage. Normally ovens of this size are rated at 1200W.

However, this oven uses the extra power for quick preheating as well as for cooking particular food items that require extra heat. Just make sure you provide it with proper ventilation.

While spending a hefty amount on a non-convection oven may seem unsavory for most, its the internal smart technology that should be the deciding factor for this oven.

Basically, if you want smart sensors and ICs to take care of your toasting and cooking, then this is the best toaster oven for frozen pizza.

If you're looking for a functional and efficient toaster oven, the Breville model is worth considering. With multiple cooking options such as baking, broiling, reheating, and toasting, this compact oven heats up quickly and cooks evenly. 

Its stainless exterior makes it an attractive addition to any kitchen, and it comes with a broiling pan for added convenience.

The Breville toaster oven is also easy to clean, and its temperature accuracy ensures consistent results. 

Overall, this is one of the best-designed small appliances on the market, and its high quality makes it a top choice for cooking enthusiasts.

5. Hamilton Beach 31156 – With Slot Toaster – Single 9″ Pizza

This is a fancy little machine by Hamilton Beach can help you with both your frozen pizza woes as well as with your breakfast.

The Slot Toaster on top of this oven can quickly crisp up your bagels and sliced bread. As such, if you are in a hurry, this can come in handy.

As far as the interior capacity goes, it is actually on the smaller side of the spectrum. The toaster can only fit about a 9 inch pizza. However, the two distinct rack positions should give you some control over your cooking.

While the pop-up toaster wouldn’t matter much as far as the Pizza is concerned, we just find this to be a very neat feature to have in a kitchen.

Therefore, if you seek versatility, then this is the best toaster oven for frozen pizza available for quite cheap.

For the past three years, I've been using this toaster oven/toaster combo every day for toast and about once a week for the oven, and it still looks brand new. 

It's incredibly easy to clean and works like a charm. Not only can I toast buns in the lower part, but it's also wide enough for larger bread sizes, making it a perfect fit for my tiny kitchen. 

With a tray for crumbs, a user-friendly timer, and the ability to toast bagels, this space-saving product is a must-have.

I highly recommend it for toasting, warming up food, and more - switching from a toaster to an oven is a breeze. Overall, I couldn't be happier with my purchase!

How To Find the Right Toaster Oven?

Here are some of the things that you should be looking for while selecting your toaster oven for frozen pizza.

Budget

The price of the oven often relates to its size, number of features, the quality and its durability.

If you are an everyday or a frequent baker, then you should get a high-end product which can work for you for a longer period of time.

However, if you seldom bake or are learning to bake then you don’t need to spend much on it and going for a cheaper option would suffice.

Size

The size of the toaster oven should be judged by three factors:

1. Size of the Pizza you will reheat
2. Size of the area in your kitchen where you will place the oven
3. The amount of people you need to serve.

While most toaster ovens are generally compact and small, you can find large options that fit two large pizzas. Source: Oster

You will notice that some toaster ovens can only fit up to a single 9″ pizza whereas, others can fit multiple 16″ pizzas.

Therefore, the size you choose will depend upon your serving needs.

For personal use, a simple 12″ toaster oven would suffice. However, if you are running a small commercial kitchen, you may want to look into bigger options.

Special Features

Some toaster ovens have rotisserie mechanism others have pop-up toaster or an air fryer.

There are so many special features that a toaster can come equipped with. Of course, the more special features in an oven, the more expensive it will be.

However, if you want to combine two appliances in one to promote a clean and a clutter free kitchen, then looking into special features may help.

How Does Toaster Oven Reheating Compare with Microwave Reheating?

Microwave ovens are generally the go to choice for many who want to reheat their left over food.

However, there is a start difference between reheating in a microwave oven as compared to reheating in a toaster oven.

Microwave ovens heat from the inside out and therefore are great for foods that have a high water content/

Toaster ovens, on the other hand, heat from the outside in. As such, they are much better for baked products like pizza.

If you want to retain as much of the original taste of the pizza as possible, then toaster oven would ideally be the best choice to go for.

Basically, toaster ovens activate the processor of Retrogration which gives the toasted food its distinct taste and crispy texture.

Comparison with a Regular Oven

A regular oven can also certainly be used for reheating, however, their size and their wattage rating is certainly an overkill for reheating a mere pizza slice or two.

Plus a regular oven takes longer to reach the desired temperature due to their size.

Therefore, for small meal portions, it is recommended to employ the use of a toaster oven.

How to Reheat Pizza in a Toaster Oven?

If you want to capture the same rich flavor of all the ingredients that you get in a freshly baked pizza, you need to learn how to reheat your pizza in a toaster oven properly.

In the following guide, we have highlighted some important tips and tricks to get the most out of your frozen pizzas.

Learn how to store and warm up your frozen or leftover pizza in a toaster oven the right way.

Basically, the process is quite simple.

You need to start with preheating your oven. Preheating is important in order to bring the oven to the desired temperature.

You can preheat your toaster oven to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

You can then place the slices of your pizza on the grill or on the baking pan. You can also place an aluminum foil on the racks if you do not want food to splatter.

It is important to place the pizza on the middle rack. Do not keep it close to the baking heating element.

Once placed, you can bake the pizza for 10 minutes while 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

You can also use the Toast function of your toaster oven whereby both heating elements will turn on. You can reduce the temperature as well as the time to 5- 7 minutes if using the toast mode.

If you are reheating the pizza for the first time in your toaster oven, it is important to check on it on regular interval.

Once you have removed your reheated pizza oven, make sure that you remove any spills, slime or splatter from the oven.

Final Words

Here we had a look at some of the best toaster ovens for frozen pizza. We had a look at affordable as well as some of the more high end models.

The bottom line here is that toaster ovens come in a variety of sizes, budget and features. If you need a regular toaster oven without any other special function like a convection fan, then you can find one for pretty cheap.

On the higher end side, sky is the limit. You can find extra large toaster ovens with smart feature as well as other built in functions like a slot toaster and even an air fryer.

FAQs:

1. What are the best toaster ovens for frozen pizza?

List of Best Toaster Ovens for Frozen Pizza that we tested.

1. Hamilton Beach 31123D – Convection – Single 12″ Pizza
2. Hamilton Beach 31401 – Budget Option – Single 9″ Pizza
3. Oster Extra Large Toaster Oven – Convection – Double 16″ Pizza
4. Breville BOV650XL Smart Toaster Oven – Single 12″ Pizza
5. Hamilton Beach 31156 – With Slot Toaster – Single 9″ Pizza

2. How do you make pizza crispy in a toaster oven?

To achieve the crispy pizza, seal in moisture by spritzing the top of your slice with a light coating of water (really! ), then place pizza directly on the oven rack and bake for 7 minutes at 425°. That is roughly half the time required to preheat a conventional oven!

3. Can you cook hot pockets in a toaster oven?

You certainly can. Preheat the toaster oven to 350°F. Remove the Hot Pocket from its packaging and place it on a baking sheet for the toaster oven. Cook the Hot Pockets in the toaster oven for 20–25 minutes, or until crispy and golden brown.

4. What temperature do you cook pizza in a fan oven?

The optimal temperature for cooking homemade pizza in a conventional oven is approximately 250 degrees celcius (about 500 degrees farenheit). This is approximately gas mark 9 for gas mark ovens. Additionally, if your oven is fan assisted, ensure that the fan is turned on.

5. How do you reheat pizza in the oven without drying it out?

We recently discovered an effective method of reheating: Arrange the chilled slices on a rimmed baking sheet, tightly cover with aluminum foil, and place the baking sheet on the lowest rack of a cold oven. Then preheat the oven to 275 degrees Fahrenheit and warm the pizza for 25 to 30 minutes.