Who doesn’t like a serving of freshly baked potatoes? After all, there are so many toppings and seasoning that you can experiment with a serving of baked potatoes.
As such, not only are they simple to cook, you can essentially turn them into a delicacy.
Whether it is a quick healthy meal of baked potatoes that you are looking for, or whether you are expecting guests at home, you need an appliance that can do justice to the taste and texture of the potatoes.
Microwave ovens can also cook potatoes, however, they cannot bake them. Potatoes cooked in a microwave oven turn out to be soft and soggy without any crispy texture.
On the other hand, toaster ovens, like regular ovens, are your best bet to achieving the perfect potatoes.
In this article we will look at some of the best toaster ovens for potatoes. We will also briefly review things that you should look for.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from the product affiliate links.
Also Read: Best Toaster Ovens for Frozen Pizza
List of Best Toaster Ovens for Potatoes in 2020
We have selected the following keeping the above short guide into consideration.
- BLACK+DECKER TO3280SSD – Budget Digital Toaster Oven
- Hamilton Beach 31107D – Dual Racks
- Cuisinart TOA-60 – Airfryer and Toaster Oven Combo
- COSORI 30L – Multifunction Digital Toaster Oven
- Breville BOV845BSS – Smart Toaster Oven
1. BLACK+DECKER TO3280SSD – Budget Digital Toaster Oven
If you are looking for a budget option, then we highly recommend this particular toaster oven by Black+Decker.
It is a small oven, but the thing we like about it despite its size, is that it has a rather taller cooking chamber. As such, the potatoes that you bake will be at a relatively safe distance from the heating elements.
Other than that, it has fully digital controls. Therefore, you can set precise temperature and cooking cycle and also choose among the many preset functions that include baking, broiling, toasting, reheating etc.
The oven has a 120 minute timer which is higher than our minimum recommended timer of 60 minutes.
Also, despite being a budget digital toaster oven, it also offer the convection feature. Therefore, you should be able to try out both baking methods i.e with convection fan on and with convection fan off. They will both give you different results.
Just make sure you adjust the cooking temperature when using the convection feature.
All in all, if you are looking for a small size option for personal use, then this is the best toaster oven for potatoes in our opinion.
Also Read: Best Toaster Ovens for Broiling
2. Hamilton Beach 31107D – Dual Racks
This convection toaster oven is a step up in terms of size as compared to the previous BLACK+DECKER TO3280SSD reviewed above. Not only does it have larger dimensions, it also offer dual racks.
As such, if it is a baked potatoes feast that you want to cook, then you should be able to do so thanks to its larger size.
The many rack adjustment options can allow you to experiment with the distance that you want to keep the potatoes from the heating elements. This in turn can result in different texture and taste.
One thing to note here is that this oven is more than just suitable for baking potatoes. It even offers a rotisserie function. Therefore, you can even roast a whole 5lb chicken in it.
Like the previous oven listed here, this too has a 120 minute timer. However, the only relatively down side to this appliance is that it does not offer digital controls. Instead, it relies on the old knob controls.
Price wise, this is quite competitive. Keeping its larger size in mind, the price here is quite justifiable.
In the end, you need to gauge your size requirements. If you truly need a relatively larger option, then this is the best toaster oven for potatoes in our opinion. Otherwise, you can stick with the smaller oven above.
3. Cuisinart TOA-60 – Airfryer and Toaster Oven Combo
This a more of an option for hobbyists. If you are someone who loves healthy cooking and likes to experiment with different cooking styles, then you may like this model.
This is also one of the most popular toaster ovens out there for the simple reason that it combines the functionality of a convection toaster oven with an Air Fryer. All that at a relatively affordable price tag.
While baking potatoes in a toaster oven is one way to cook, you can also Air Fry them for a completely different texture and taste. There are myriad of recipes covering how to air fry potatoes.
The oven has a relatively small oven chamber with a 0.6 Cubic Feet capacity, and a shorter cooking cycle of 60 minutes as compared to the previous ovens, but it is quite sufficient to bake potatoes.
This particular model lacks digital controls, Cuisinart does have another model, the TOA-65, which offers digital controls. However, it is significantly more expensive.
In the end, if you are also hunting for an air fryer, then this is the best toaster oven for potatoes.
4. COSORI 30L – Multifunction Digital Toaster Oven
COSORI 30L is a large capacity toaster oven with 1.0 cubic feet of volume. However, what truly separates this from the rest of the ovens here is not just its size, but its myriad of features.
COSORI calls this a 12-in-1 oven because not only does it feature the regular bake, broiling and reheating functions, it also offers rotisserie, dehydrator, air fryer and separate automated functions for cooking pizza, roasting, toasting, cooking bagels, fermenting and for keeping the food warm.
Therefore, this oven is the jack of all trades as it automates most of the cooking for you. You can choose and set the function easily using its comprehensive digital controls.
Unfortunately, with larger size and a larger set of functions comes a higher price tag as well. This oven is on the expensive side of the price spectrum.
However, if you consider the amount of features it combines in one, then you may find the price quite justifiable.
All in all, if you want a versatile option, then we find this to be the best toaster oven for potatoes.
5. Breville BOV845BSS – Smart Toaster Oven
Breville BOV845BSS smart oven may seem like any other digital toaster oven on the surface, but currently this is the epitome of technological advancements in this particular home appliance.
The key difference between this smart oven and the dumb ovens above is the introduction of the proprietary Element IQ technology.
With this technology, the toaster oven basically senses and automatically makes changes to the temperature and time based on whats being cooked. The best result is achieved in relation to the repeated results Breville has tested in their own kitchen.
Just to give you an example, when using the toasting function, you can choose the levels of browness that you need on your toast and hit the start button, the oven will automatically set the timer and temperature for that result to be achieved.
Unfortunately though, all that automation and smart technology comes with a pretty hefty price tag. The Breville BOV845BSS is among the most expensive toaster ovens of its size category.
In the end, if your budget allows you to experiment with an advanced appliance, then this is among the best toaster ovens for potatoes.
Things to Look for If You Are Baking Potatoes
When choosing the right toaster oven for baked potatoes, there isn’t much that you need to look for. Any regular toaster oven with bake function should be able to handle the cooking for you.
However, when you go over the myriad of recipes online, there are few important consideration that should be kept in mind.
This is an important consideration. You need to look for a toaster oven that has a cooking timer of at least an hour.
It takes about 45-55 minutes to bake a potato depending on the recipe you are using.
Therefore, a small and a budget toaster oven with a mere 30 minutes cycle would not be ideal.
Potatoes come in various sizes and therefore your toaster oven should be large enough to support majority of the sizes.
A very important point to note here is that the oven chamber should be large enough so that the potatoes do not come into close contact with the heating elements.
Otherwise, it may lead to damage to your toaster oven and is also a fire hazard.
No need to worry about this much. To bake potatoes most recipes would suggest setting the temperature at 400° Fahrenheit.
Fortunately, all toaster ovens can support this degree of temperature.
Do You Need the Convection Feature?
To bake potatoes, you don’t really need the convection feature. A regular oven with bake function would do just fine at 400° Fahrenheit.
Should you choose to use the convection feature, you will need to adjust the temperature typically by lowering it by 25° Fahrenheit i.e 375° Fahrenheit.
You may notice that a potato baked with convection feature on may have a different texture as compared to that with a regular bake setting.
As you can see there is a variety of best toaster ovens for potatoes. Some are budget models, others are expensive with an array of features.
In the end, the one you choose would depend upon your budget and your needs. For example, if you need an oven just for mere potatoes, then you don’t need to invest in a multifunction or a smart oven at all.
However, if you prefer to automate your cooking process not just for potatoes but for various other foods, then you may need to pay extra for the features.