Kitchen Gearoid
best toaster ovens for reheating food

5 Best Toaster Ovens for Reheating Food in 2020

If you have some leftover food or if you refrigerate cooked food to be consumed later, then you need a proper appliance for reheating.

Basically, there are four common appliances that come to mind when reheating: stove, regular oven, microwave oven, and a toaster oven.

The most common one among them are the microwave oven and a toaster oven.

While microwave ovens are great for instant heating up food, they do not retain the same taste as the original on certain foods.

For this reason most prefer reheating there food in a toaster oven.

As such, in this article we will review the best toaster ovens for reheating food.

DisclosureAs an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from the product affiliate links.

Also Read: Best Toaster Ovens for Frozen Pizza

Comparison of Best Toaster Oven for Reheating Food

Hamilton Beach 31401 - Regular Budget Oven

One of the most affordable regular toaster oven

  • Fits Single 9 Inch Pizza
  • 30 mins Timer
  • Knob Control
  • Manual Reheating
Sale
Hamilton Beach 31107D - Large Knob Control

A larger knob controlled toaster oven that is still quite within the affordable range.

  • Fits Two 12 Inch Pizza
  • Knob Controlled
  • Manual Reheating
  • 120 minutes time
Sale
Breville BOV450XL - Smart Oven

A mini smart oven with intelligent features.

  • Fits 11 Inch Pizza
  • Digital Controls – Auto Reheating
  • Smart Oven with Proprietary Smart Element IQ technology
  • 8 Cooking Presets – Automatically Adjusts the Time and Temperature
Breville BOV650XL - Smart Oven

Toaster Oven with high tech features. It is expensive, but gives perfect results.

  • Fits Single 12 Inch Pizza
  • Digital Controls – Auto Reheating
  • Smart Oven with Proprietary Smart Element IQ technology
  • 8 Cooking Presets – Automatically Adjusts the Time and Temperature
Sale
Oster Extra Large Oven

This large and expensive toaster oven can 2 x 16″ pizzas and comes with digital control with plenty of presets including a dehydrator.

  • Auto Reheat Function
  • Fits 2 x 16″ Pizzas, 14 Slices of Bread
  • french doors
  • Digital Controls with Cooking Presets for various foods.

Reheating Food in a Toaster Oven

Reheating in a toaster oven is far simpler as compared to a regular oven. Since they have a small chamber, they heat up very quickly and therefore, you can have a quick go at your frozen, refrigerated or leftover food.

While they do take longer than a microwave oven to reheat the food, the results are generally crispier and retain the original taste.

They are great for reheating bread, pizza, bagels, meat and vegetables.

Warming in Microwave vs in Toaster Oven

Microwaves are perhaps the most obvious contender against toaster ovens when it comes to reheating.

While microwaves are fast, they do not necessarily have the best results.

Here is a summary of the two.

 Toaster OvenMicrowave
Cooking ResultCrispySoft
Cooking / Heating TimeAverageFast
Cleaning and MaintenanceToughEasy
Energy Efficiency1200-1800 watts ; Consumes More Energy700-1300 watts ; Consumes Less Energy
SizeCan be found in very small sizeLarger than an average toaster oven
InstallationEasy to install and operateEasy to install and operate
SafetyRequires proper ventilation and vigilanceRelative safe to operate
Countertop ConvenienceSmall and CompactMost models can be fitted in kitchen cabinets freeing up countertop space.
Frozen Food Convenience Takes time to defrostIdeal for defrosting

Basically, when it comes to browning, toasting and crisping, toaster ovens win, hands down. The heating element on the top and bottom provide direct heat so that surfaces become crisp.

Microwaves on the other hand can result in the food ending up as soggy or completely devoid of water. You cannot achieve the crisp result.

Also Read: Toaster Oven vs Microwave Oven

How to Reheat Food in a Toaster Oven?

Reheating in a toaster oven isn’t a difficult task. Generally there are two ways to reheat leftover in a toaster oven.

Automatic

best toaster ovens for reheating food
Digital Toaster Ovens have a Dedicated Reheat Function

This is the most obvious choice if your toaster oven has a “Reheat” function.

Many toaster ovens, especially with digital controls, have a dedicated preset function for Reheating.

This takes all the guess work out of the cooking as the toaster oven takes care of settings of the right temperature and timer for you.

Manual

Basically, to reheat the food, set the temperature at 350°F or below. You will need to do some guess work on the time though as each food type and its size requires a different amount of time to reheat.

Generally, for foods like pieces of bread and pizza, 5 – 7 minutes should be good.

The amount of time also depends upon the size of the oven chamber and the proximity of the food to the heating elements.

What Can You Reheat in a Toaster Oven?

While there are myriad of things that can be reheated, as a general rule of thumb you should avoid foods that are rather in liquid form or do no have a crust like soups, curry, stews, rice, noodles and even boiled vegetables as they are better suited for a microwave oven.

Instead, you can reheat, any and all sorts of bread, fried food, roasted foods, baked products, grilled meats, pizza, sandwich, potatoes etc.

Also Read: Best Toaster Ovens for Potatoes

List of Best Toaster Ovens for Reheating Food in 2020

The following, in our opinion, are the best toaster ovens for reheating as far as their functions and price point is concerned.

  1. Hamilton Beach 31401 – Affordable Small Sized
  2. Hamilton Beach 31107D – Large Double Rack
  3. Breville BOV450XL – Mini Smart Digital Toaster Oven
  4. Breville BOV650XL – Regular Sized Smart Digital Option
  5. Oster French – Extra Large Oven for Feasts

1. Hamilton Beach 31401 – Affordable Small Sized

Hamilton Beach 31401 Affordable Option Fits Single 9-inch Pizza

The cheapest option in this list. This is a regular toaster oven excellent for those looking for a simple toasting appliance for their frozen pizza.

If you need a simple, compact and a highly affordable toaster oven for reheating your food, then we recommend this Hamilton Beach 31401.

Note that this is a regular toaster oven and does not feature the convection fan. If you are unaware, convection fans are generally used to circulate the warm air evenly across the oven chamber.

For reheating though, you won’t notice a huge difference especially in such a small oven if it lacks the convection fan.

This toaster oven has a low 1100 Watts power rating with a cooking timer of maximum 30 minutes. As such, for quick reheating or making quick toasts and snacks, this little device is excellent for your kitchen countertop.

As far as the size is concerned, it can fit 4 slices of toaster or about a 9″ pizza.

All in all, if you are short on kitchen counter space or if you are looking for an affordable option, then this is the best toaster oven for reheating food in our opinion.

The only drawback here is that this is not a digital oven and therefore does not have any preset for reheating. Therefore, you will need to adjust the timer and the temperature yourself depending upon the food that you reheat.

2. Hamilton Beach 31107D – Large Double Rack

Sale
Hamilton Beach 31401 - Affordable Large Capacity Toaster Oven

This toaster oven has enough capacity to fit a family sized chicken or even 2 x 12″ pizza thanks to double rack options.

Like the previously mentioned Hamilton Beach 31401, Hamilton Beach 31107D is also NOT a digital oven, however, it has a much larger capacity.

The oven can’t just fit one 12″ pizza, but two on its dual racks. Therefore, if you like warming up feasts for crowds then this is an excellent option to have.

Basically, this oven is more than just capable of reheating food. It has a cooking timer of 120 minutes, the size to fit a family sized chicken and comes with all the accessories such as baking pans and racks to prepare a complex recipe.

Moreover, Hamilton Beach 31107D also offers the convection fan. With the convection feature on, you will need to adjust your recipes a bit, but you can get an overall evenly cooked food as the heat is circulated to all the nooks and crannies consistently.

In the end, if you need a large capacity option to reheat or to, perhaps even, cook large portions of meals, then this the best toaster oven for reheating food at an affordable price tag.

Also Read: Best Toaster Ovens with Rotisserie

3. Breville BOV450XL – Mini Smart Digital Toaster Oven

Sale
Breville BOV450XL - Small Sized Oven with Intelligent Feature

This toaster oven employs some of the best technologies this category has to offer. With fully automated digital controls and sensors, this toaster oven is excellent for reheating, as well as for cooking food.

There are digital ovens and then there are smart ovens. Smart ovens employ the best this industry has to offer. Unfortunately, with high tech comes a higher price tag.

Breville BOV450XL is the smallest of the Breville Toaster Ovens that employ the Smart Element IQ Technology, however, despite its size, it is one of the best model out there not just for reheating but for cooking meals.

The oven features 4 Quartz heating elements with a whopping 1800 Watts power rating. This amount of power enables the oven to preheat very quickly which in turn results in much faster reheating of your food.

The defining feature of this and the rest of Breville smart ovens is that they come equipped with Smart Element IQ technology. With this technology, the oven senses and adjusts the temperature depending upon the food being cooked or reheated.

Thus as far as quality of meal goes, this oven takes the cake.

The only drawback is that it is fairly expensive. Other ovens, some even much larger than this, are available at a fairly lower price tag.

All in all, if you need a digital and fully automated mini option, then this is the best toaster oven for reheating food.

4. Breville BOV650XL – Regular Sized Smart Digital Option

Breville BOV650XL Smart Toaster Oven Fits Single 12 Inch Pizza

This toaster oven, albeit expensive, uses its proprietary Smart Element IQ technology for unprecedented control on heat. It can cook, toast and defrost evenly even without the convection feature.

Like the previous oven, this is also a smart oven that employs Breville’s proprietary Smart Element IQ technology.

However, this has a larger size and therefore should be able to handle large sized meals and portions.

As far as the features are concerned, it offers the same set of features as the Breville BOV450XL. In other words, it also offers 8 cooking presets including reheating functions and also 4 Quartz heating elements.

All in all, if you need a family sized smart digital option, then this is the best toaster oven for reheating food and also for cooking.

5. Oster French – Extra Large Oven for Feasts

Sale
Oster Extra Large Oven

This large and expensive toaster oven can 2 x 16″ pizzas and comes with digital control with plenty of presets including a dehydrator and automatic reheating.

This oven is big. This is a toaster oven that is fit for feasts. To give you an idea, it can fit 2 x 16″ pizzas on its dual racks. That is a lot of space.

From turkey to family sized chicken this oven can fit them all.

While there are plenty of extra large toaster ovens out there, what separate this from the rest is that it has digital controls and also a dedicated digital function for reheating.

The benefit of this is obvious, it leaves the guesswork out of your cooking since the oven automatically adjusts the temperature and the timer for you.

Of course an oven as large as this may not be everyone’s cup of team since it requires a large family to justify its purpose. On top of that, it will also take up plenty of counter space.

However, if you love cooking oversized meals or if you generally bake, broil or roast a lot, then this options makes sense.

In the end, if you came here specifically looking for an extra large digital option then this is the best toaster oven for reheating food.

Conclusion

The best toaster ovens for reheating food, in our opinion, are those that have dedicated preset function for reheating. Why? Because this literally saves you from the hassle of guess work.

The bottom line is that while toaster ovens generally take marginally longer to reheat food compared to a microwave oven, they are best at retaining the original taste of certain foods especially those that are baked, grilled, broiled, roasted or steamed.

About

Each and every specification for a certain kitchen appliance matters. At KitchenGearoid, instead of looking at the appliance specifications with a birds eye view, we aim to provide a microscopic view with the goal to detail each and every aspect.

We are members of Amazon.com Associates Program. This is an affiliate program from which we earn commission based advertisement fees from all qualifying purchases through our links. Learn more.